Not people making cooking their hobby, but people not wanting to buy read-made food and learn how to cook well?
Later in life, JC said that there is a certain value of easier methods, quickly prepared meals and in some later books she gave instructions that too less time and effort. Also, JC had a career out of cooking. Ultimately, I would indeed put the misunderstanding down to different generations not understanding each others daily life and life style. JP wanted to challenge herself, JC wanted to learn how to cook well. These were two slighlty different approaches. JP wanted to make every recipe just once and possibly later come back to some; JC wanted to cook every recipe repeatedly until she nailed it and that was a completely different approach.
Also, I believe in her time, challenges were not as common as in the early s or today. It is certainly true that the project revived interest in Julia Child and helped a new generation see her in a different light. And Julia needed to cook every recipe repeatedly in order to ensure that the recipes would turn out the way she intended when people who may or may not have known anything about how to cook tried them at home.
One of the very interesting parts of the book of letters between Julia and Avis Devoto was when Avis would send Julia bags of flour and canned vegetables and things that Americans would be using to cook with that might be different in France where the recipes were being developed. So I think that was less a difference in style between JC and JP and more of a difference in the overall project they were doing. JC was creating a cookbook; JP was using it to cook.
Every generation has its own set of challenges. Wonderful explanation. But i also believe Julie Childs was self centered as most artists are At 81 i am trying to learn to cook.
Thank you to the movie and these comments. Though that may have changed later in life after she was became well-known. Who knows. At any rate, thanks for the comment and good luck learning to cook! You realy nailed it! Your post and your reactions later on, aswell as some reactions from guests…. This all realy feels right. Thank you for you work and trouble to answer this question thorow and right. You are commenting using your WordPress. You are commenting using your Google account.
You are commenting using your Twitter account. You are commenting using your Facebook account. Notify me of new comments via email. Notify me of new posts via email. Why Am I Here? Julia on Julie Thursday, January 16, Shapiro writes: Julia was teaching people to use their senses when they cooked, because she thought the senses belonged in every well-run kitchen, like good knives.
Posted by lessisenough Filed in Julia Child. Mariana Says:. Larf Says:. Heather Stuebe Says:. T Ross Says:. Nelly Says:. Robyn Says:. Kristina Says:. Lisa Says:. Ami Says:. Arianna Says:. It is No. It's what many, though not all, bloggers aspire to -- that one day what we deem fit to blog might someday catch the eye of an editor and the subject line "Book Deal" might pop up in our inboxes.
Few of us lowly bloggers will ever find Powell's success. Technorati, a blog search engine, tracks blog publishing and there are reportedly million blogs on the Web. The chances of getting a book deal like Powell's are few and far between. If they don't like you, they're either jealous or sanctimonious morons: unworthy of attention either way. And another Kristin wrote, "Who knows why anyone would spend their energy hating you Also coming to Powell's defense, food writer David Leite of Leite's Culineria responded to Willis with the following:.
I don't believe that Julie Powell set out to be a celebrity or planned to be disrespectful of Julia. Celebrity came about through an utterly unique idea that has spawned countless copycat and less interesting projects. Snark aka disrespect is part of Julie' style -- just spend time reading some of her other writing.
Adam Roberts of the prominent food blog Amateur Gourmet is a cook and blogger-turned-author like Powell. He doesn't see what the harm is in eating and writing about it.
It's about having a singular voice that rises above the fray, connects to an audience, and inspires others to cook," he told ABC News. Whether they like her writing style or the way she cooks a poulet de Bresse , all seem to agree on one thing.
And I was a little resentulf that I didn't get it. That kind of drives me crazy. What did your husband say about the movie? Did he have any input? Neither of us did. Nora met us, and she asked me very scary questions, and she went and wrote the script, and it became a different thing. Eric and I didn't really directly contribute to the movie. When you watch the movie, it's like his office, it's very, very creepy. He's freaking out a little bit about the movie.
Aside from the book deal, what was the biggest thing you got out of the project in the end? I think the reason that I came to Mastering the Art to begin with, is that there's something in that book besides the recipes and the authentic cooking course that you go through. There's a sense of confidence and bravery in the book, and I was just inspired by it. Not just the recipes. I had turned into a writer, I had a tone. I think really what Julia Child does, it's not just about teaching us to cook.
It was gleefully reported that neither Child nor her editor, Judith Jones, had thought much of Powell's project. Powell wrote an editorial for The New York Times piercing the sanctimony of the organic food movement and made herself a whole new group of enemies.
The recent report that organic food is no healthier than conventionally grown food should give her some vindication. The news that her next book, Cleaving: A Story of Marriage, Meat, and Obsession, reveals the extramarital affair she had with an old friend was met with both eyerolls and raised eyebrows, and her publisher's decision to push back the book's release date and screenwriter Nora Ephron's omission of the affair from the film were viewed as highly suspicious.
Early reviews of the film complain that the character based on Powell played by Amy Adams isn't nearly as likable or interesting as the Julia Child character played by Meryl Streep , and food bloggers, many of whom were invited to advance screenings, are taking the film's release as an excuse to revisit their issues with Powell, which boil down to one complaint: she doesn't really know how to cook. In the seven years since Powell started her blog, the premise seems to have gone from Julie and Julia to Julie vs.
Julia, with Julia winning. What's unfair about this is the fact that Powell never claimed to be a great cook. She was clear, from her project's inception, that it was simply a conceit: not to get a book deal, but to get a life.
0コメント